Make up the members of the female version of "SuperM"

Make up the members of the female version of "SuperM"

女性版「SuperM」のメンバーを構成する

What if there was a female version of SuperM? Likely members

★　"What if there was a female version of SuperM?"... Posts like this have become a hot topic in Korean online communities.

Netizens are speculating about the lineup.


No specific plans have been announced for a female version of SuperM to date, but posts are abuzz in online communities.


The member who has been mentioned the most is Red Velvet's Seulgi.


She is highly praised for her all-round abilities, being good at both dancing and singing.


Other names that stand out include Girls' Generation's Taeyeon, and aespa's Karina and Winter, who debuted last November.


★　"SuperM" is a seven-member boy group under SM.


Since it is made up of famous members from existing groups such as Taemin (SHINee), Kai (EXO), Baekhyun (EXO), and Taeyong (NCT), it is called the K-POP Avengers, or SM All-Stars.


(Reactions from Korean online communities)
▼"I think Taeyong and Seulgi are absolutely necessary"
▼"Seulgi is unconditional. She has great abilities. She's also a good dancer"
▼"When I saw the title, Seulgi immediately came to mind"
▼"Why does everyone say Seulgi is unconditional?"
▼"Because she has a hexagon of abilities. She's an all-rounder and balanced member"
▼"I think Taeyong will turn it down"
▼"The vocal members will be Taeyong, Seulgi, and Winter"
▼"Taeyong, Seulgi, Winter, Wendy, Karina, Hyoyeon, Yuna.


The members are good at vocals, and the two Medals are also good at vocals. And Yuna in the center."


▼"I thought that SNSD and Red Velvet were very far apart in age, but Yuna and Irene are only one year apart. Even if you look at Irene and others, she's four years apart from Seulgi."


▼"-Leader: BoA
-Men: Taeyeon
-Medals: Hyoyeon
-Ribbon/Red Velvet: Seulgi
-Center: Yuna"


▼"Why do you think most people choose Karina?"


▼"She's in the center and has a beautiful figure, They don't lack skills either."
▼"There's still not enough information to know the extent of aespa's abilities."
▼"-Vocals: Taeyeon
-Dance/Rap: Hyoyeon
-All-rounder: Seulgi
-Vocals: Joy
-Dance: Karina
-Foreign Language Rap: Gisele"
▼"I don't think there will ever be a female SuperM."


SuperM was conscious of BTS and competed with a 7-member group, but this backfired and they didn't get very good results.


If you compare the individual members' ranks, it wouldn't have been surprising if they had achieved equal results.


However, because the selection process placed too much importance on the ranks of the members, the image of a ragtag group may have been too strong.


If they were conscious of BTS, they would have been better off sticking to their team style rather than borrowing from the existing ranks of the members.


It was a hastily put together team that only wanted to get results, so it was inevitable that they would have remained a simple all-star group...


If it were just a unit activity, it would be enough to add together the individual members' images, but a new group would have to develop or create a new image for the group itself.


That's why SuperM couldn't compete fairly with BTS.


Even in baseball, an all-star team doesn't necessarily win when playing against a team from a single baseball team.


It's the same thing.


The key is not to add rank, but to increase the output of the team.


If SM were to imagine a female version of "SuperM," they should not choose members based on their "rank," but rather select members who will maximize the output of the team.


To do that, they should have at least two of the following: "unique characters" and "good singing, dancing, and visuals." They have one and are above average in another - I'd expect an idol with "Super" in their name to at least meet those criteria.


So I've chosen my own version of the female version of SM (including its current members), "SuperM."


♦ First up is Taeyeon (Girls' Generation). Her singing and visuals are impeccable. She herself seems to dislike dancing, but I don't think she's bad at it (or maybe she's good?).


There are now more idols who are good at dancing, so I wouldn't call Taeyeon particularly good, but she still passes the test.


♦ Next is Seulgi (Red Velvet). She has no weaknesses. She has all three qualities, including dancing. She is one of the members who seems likely to have more energy than expected if she were to work in "SuperM".


♦ After much deliberation about adding three members from Girls' Generation and at least one more, the name that came to mind was Jessica.


Yuna had too much of an actress image.


There was a fear that including Yuna would result in a repeat of the boys' group "SuperM".


Hence she was cut.


The same reason was true for Seohyun.


Tiffany's singing and visuals are passable, but her dancing isn't that close.


Her singing is so-so Although she is good, she doesn't have a strong personality.


If she was good at dancing, it's a shame that her visuals would not be able to shine.


Tiffany was kept as a substitute for Jessica, and Jessica became the other member from Girls' Generation.


Since she was dropped from the group, it's hopeless for her to join SuperM, but with Jessica's addition, I saw her as a member who could bring Girls' Generation back to their heyday.


I thought that I should at least imagine that dream, so I added her.


That's why I included Tiffany as a substitute.


♦ Wendy (Red Velvet)'s singing ability is definitely necessary along with Taeyeon. Since she was in a serious accident, I don't expect too much from her dancing.


However, her singing ability more than makes up for that.
The double vocals with Taeyeon are intense.


♦ Crystal. I would have liked to have her if Sulli was alive. Though the members are only visually appealing, their strong personalities would have been able to be fully displayed in the female version of "SuperM".


Sulli was the one who wanted to soar into the world as a K-pop idol more than anyone else.


She looked up to Hara, who had been a huge success traveling between Japan and Korea as a member of KARA, as an older sister (from poor to idol), and there must have been a strong overlap between her own dreams and aspirations.


After achieving unexpected success, Hara regretted returning the affection of her kin (older brother ⇒ mother).


Sulli (formerly of f(X)), who deepened her friendship with Hara, seems to have been in a similar situation.


Although Crystal and Sulli had ample talent, they were unable to achieve long-term success as K-pop idols or talents during their activities with f(x), which distanced itself from entertainment.


In place of Sulli, I would like Crystal to succeed as a K-pop singer (actress).
It would be a shame to let her go, as she has all three qualities: singing, dancing, and visuals.


If the sister duo of Jessica and Krystal debut in "SuperM," the possibility of a big break will increase.


Of course, it would be a dream lineup...


♦ Irene (Red Velvet). Although her image was tarnished by the power harassment scandal last year, she is undoubtedly a member who suits the glamor and big stage.


Her singing and dancing are only average, but her visuals are overwhelming.


I would definitely like to add her. I would like Taeyeon to fully demonstrate her singing ability, and Irene may actually be the perfect person to be the internal leader.


♦ Karina (aespa).
I was torn between this and Joy (Red Velvet), but it's a little sad that there are no new faces.


aespa has also been featured prominently in Billboard as a girl group that will be active this year.
Though their singing leaves something to be desired, their popularity is soaring, and their dance moves, which match their futuristic visuals, are more than just powerful.


With them at the center with the legends by their side, the prospects for the next generation of girls will surely open up.


And so, I have created my own dream lineup of SM members (the female version of "SuperM").




<script type="text/javascript" src="//translate.google.com/translate_a/element.js?cb=googleTranslateElementInit"></script> google-site-verification: google3493cdb2db9ede