Carlos Kleiber と Sergiu Chelibidache

Carlos Kleiber - Brahms Symphony No.4 (1st mov./ first part)


Celibidache - Brahms IV.1


二つ目の動画のコメント欄では
Kleiber か Chelibidache か、という
面白い議論が行われている。

順序をつけるのに意味はないが、

> Kleiber and Celibidache are so fundamentally different conductors
> that comparison is almost pointless, imo.
> Where Celibidache is all about sound and phrasing,
> Kleiber is about dynamics and rythm.

> Two totally different ways of music making,
> both ingenious and both entirely authentic.
> I don't want miss either of them.

というのは言い得て妙だ。