Harvard Professor Emeritus and legal scholar Alan Dershowitz discusses the raid of former New York City Mayor and President Trump's lawyer Rudy Giuliani's apartment - Via Newsmax TV's 'Saturday Report.'
Alan Morton Dershowitz (/ˈdɜːrʃəwɪts/; born September 1, 1938) is an American lawyer known for his work in U.S. constitutional law and American criminal law.
He taught at Harvard Law School from 1964 through 2013, where he was appointed as the Felix Frankfurter Professor of Law in 1993. Dershowitz is a regular media contributor, political commentator, and legal analyst. He is also a prominent voice on the Arab–Israeli conflict and has written several books on the subject. Dershowitz is known for taking on high profile and often unpopular causes and clients. As of 2009, he had won 13 of the 15 murder and attempted murder cases he handled as a criminal appellate lawyer. Dershowitz has represented celebrity clients including Mike Tyson, Patty Hearst, Leona Helmsley, Julian Assange, and Jim Bakker. Major legal victories have included two successful appeals that overturned convictions, first for Harry Reems in 1976, followed by Claus von Bülow in 1984 who had been convicted for the attempted murder of his wife, Sunny. In 1995, Dershowitz served as the appellate adviser on the O. J. Simpson murder trial, part of the legal "Dream Team", alongside Johnnie Cochran and F. Lee Bailey. Dershowitz was a member of the defense team for Harvey Weinstein in 2018 and for the first impeachment trial of President Donald Trump in 2020. He was a member of the legal defense team for Jeffrey Epstein and helped to negotiate a 2006 non-prosecution agreement on Epstein's behalf.
魔王ダーショビッツ教授の指摘にFBIの形勢が悪いと見たか。完全に流れが変わった。
CNN Hits WashPost, NY Times, NBC for Failed Retractions on False Giuliani Story
日曜日、CNNのブライアン・ステルターは、連邦捜査官が先週ルディ・ジュリアーニのアパートを家宅捜索した後、彼らがルディ・ジュリアーニに関する記事を撤回したことについて、ワシントン・ポスト、ニューヨーク・タイムズ、NBCを批判しました。
この3社は、ジュリアーニとワン・アメリカ・ニュース・ネットワークがロシアの偽情報を広めるために利用されているとFBIが警告したとする誤った報道を撤回せざるを得なくなりました。
ステルターは、自身の番組「Reliable Sources」の中で、3社がどのようにして情報源に惑わされ、すぐに誤った記事を撤回しなければならなかったのかを説明し、これを「大きな汚点」と呼びました。
ステルターは、"FBIはルディとOANにロシアの操り人形として使われるかもしれないと警告する予定だったが、実際には警告を伝えなかったというのが新しいストーリーだ "と述べました。
CNNのシニアメディアレポーターであるオリバー・ダーシーはステルターに加わり、ニュースルームが匿名の情報源からの情報を公開するかどうかを決める際に審査プロセスを用いる方法を明らかにし、そのプロセスは依然としてヒューマンエラーの影響を受けやすく、これらの情報源が間違っている可能性もあると述べました。
ダーシーは、「今回のケースでは、これらすべての報道機関でそのようなことが起こっているようです」と説明しました。肝心なのは、安全策が講じられていても、残念ながらヒューマンエラーが発生し、報道機関がこのような事態に陥ることがあるということです」。
さらにステルター氏は、このような事件はメディアの信用を失墜させるものだとし、「このような大規模なインチキ報道は、悪意のある行為者を許してしまう」と述べ、正しいことをしようとするメディアと、気にしないメディアを一緒にしてしまうことになるとしています。
どの口が言う
On Sunday, CNN’s Brian Stelter criticized The Washington Post, New York Times and NBC about their retracting of stories regarding Rudy Giuliani after federal investigators raided his apartment last week.
The three outlets were forced to publicly retract their earlier false reporting that the FBI warned both Giuliani and One America News Network that they were being used in order to spread Russian disinformation.
On his show, "Reliable Sources," Stelter broke down how the outlets were misled by their sources and that they had to retract their false stories soon after, calling it a “major black eye.”
Stelter said that “[T]he new story is that FBI planned to warn Rudy and OAN they might be used as Russian puppets, but they didn’t actually deliver the warning.”
Oliver Darcy, CNN’s senior media reporter, joined Stelter, and clarified the way newsrooms use the screening process when deciding on publishing information from anonymous sources, and said that the process can still be susceptible to human error and that these sources can be wrong.
Darcy explained that “[I]n this case, that appears to be what has happened with all of these news organizations. The bottom line is there are safeguards in place, unfortunately, human error is still at play and news organizations sometimes do get burned like this.”
Stelter added that incidents like this is what helps to discredit the media, saying that “a bogus report of this magnitude allows bad faith actors” to lump media outlets that try to get it right with outlets that don’t care.
